Lightroom, picasa choosing the right software for managing your digital photos is very important because you spend a lot of time with this. First, im about to jump ship on pcs in my personal life and switch to mac. No other close competitive platform on windows, on mac you get aperture on linux there is darktable but on windows, lightroom is the. Adobe lightroom vs photoshop vs gimp vs picasa vs iphoto sadie cornelius updated. Lightroom, picasa choosing the right software for managing your digital photos is very important because you spend a lot of time with this tool. What else is good w aperture, what do you use it for. Adobe lightroom vs photoshop vs gimp vs picasa vs iphoto. Ive also considered moving the random pictures into picasa and keeping my photos in iphoto. New lightroom cc vs apple photos have many of you messed around with the new lightroom cc not the old lightroom which was renamed lightroom classic cc. Both actually store photos in a browsable folder heiarchy you have to navigate into the aperture library, but its really just folders. Dec 19, 2014 if aperture ceases to play nicely with a future major release of os x, id obviously migrate if photos proves to be a suitable replacement along the lines of final cut pro versus fcp x, a similarly jarring transition, id likely move in that direction.
Check out these free image editing alternatives to aperture. Jul 04, 2014 a quick walkthrough of an editing session in lightroom for aperture users who want to get an idea of what lightroom is like. May 29, 2017 in june of 2014, we all learned that apple had been building a whole new photo managing program called photos for mac os x. With my spiffy new canon 40d, i thought id do some tests of my own to see what kind of noise i got in my raw files at 3200 iso.
If you are an iphoto user looking to move up, then aperture might feel like a more natural transition. Can someone tell me again why the paid for lightroom is better than the free picasa. Some of us would still not be happy with apple for ditching iphotos and aperture in earlier operating systems, but the editing tools offered by photos are so well thought for beginners and hobbyists. Id like something simple and quick and easy to understand, rather than complex and timeconsuming. Adobe lightroom cc vs apple photos comparison with the release of macos 10. So i took a random shot at 3200 and loaded it onto my mac. Its equally unlikley that most people will be able to effectively use both products, which supports the. Aug 23, 2008 aperture and lightroom seem to be a matter of preference, but im not sure of what they offer in comparison to photoshop elements. Starting with macos catalina, aperture is no longer compatible with macos. Well, technically iphoto is part of the ilife suite, which costs roughly the same as aperture. What software for processing and cataloging raw images should a new.
The performance woes and underwhelming feature set in the first version tainted peoples opinions in a way that was hard for apple. This hope is more likely now that both lightroom and even iphoto can do it not to mention iview, picasa, photo mechanic, photoshop elements, etc. Jan 29, 2007 now that lightroom is out of beta, does anyone have any comparisions between it and aperture. Mac, i will give it a try and see what it has to offer compared to others. Adobe is currently promoting its creative cloud licensing, which requires you to keep paying to keep your software running something to keep in mind. Aperture vs lightroom in reply to geomaticsman dec 22, 2014 geomaticsman wrote. Given their prices, i assume that aperture and lightroom. Being an aperture user myself, i cannot really help you make that decision. Adobe lightroom gives users the option to create photo books directly from blurb. I use classic extensively and will continue to, but apple photos is a lot better than lightroom cc in many ways. How to choose the right editing program for you august 16, 20 by kasia mikoluk youve taken a set of beautiful pictures on your camera and now youre looking. Probably not lightroom, as im not overly fond of its ui.
Apple is officially removing support for its aperture image editing software in the next version of macos. The new lightroom now excels in that category as well. A few years ago, this program was more expensive than lightroom, but now its half the price. April 22, 2019 photography 10 comments to sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links.
Itll likely have much of the feature set of aperture. The list of photo managers below, are going to be listed more or less, in the. Adobe doubling down on lightroom in wake of apple s aperture announcement. Lightroom alternatives in 2020 david coleman photography. For example, if you ever wanted to stop using a mac, and start using a. Both, aperture and lightroom, allow for roundtripping which is probably what you should use. For finding a picture or a folder, picasa is very fast. Lightroom assembles images into a single catalog file. I have now learnt that there is picasa for mac but there are pros and cons vs mac s native photo manager iphoto. Secondly will either program work seamlessly with apple. Stephen hackett has a history of apple s photo management application aperture.
Has picasa for mac settled down now are most of the bugs ironed out. Comparing the various features between adobe lightroom and aperture can help you determine if the older apple product still has the chops to make it in todays competitive environment. Adobe lightroom is a good generic solution for those who may take digital images with other mobile devices. This is why i miss apple aperture and why i think apple. Photos could start to expand its metadata capabilities and add higherend editing capabilities. Although apple stopped supporting and updating aperture years ago, you could still the run the app as normal. Since then, apple has released six major macos upgrades. Pc test, our results showed that the apple imac was behind by 35% or more across the board, making the pc the clear victor. The editing tools in the high sierra version are pretty great. With iphoto, it is possible to create photo books and products through apple s service. This site contains user submitted content, comments and opinions and is for informational purposes only.
Youll need a mac with a fast processor and at least 4 gigabytes of memory. Lightroom is designed more for photography and digital media editing, improvement, and sharing. What are the differences between picasa and lightroom. Is there an aperture equivalent for windows, or do i need to use both. Or will i have either to wait for lightroom to get face recognition and mapping, or to go to mac. In the adobe lightroom vs picasa debate, it is important to recognize that each platform has a different purpose. Lightroom and aperture do a lot of the same things, but the user experience is different.
Last year john was kind enough to post an entry on his blog about how aperture and lightroom were faring in the pro community. It is looking like aperture acts the same as iphoto, and i am wondering if there is a way around this, or should i stick to picasa on my mac. Acdsee pro 2 for mac photo manager plays catchup but. Of the two, apertures plus is its ilife integration.
In iphoto, a lot seems to happen behind the scenes. Mar 02, 2020 adobes photoshop lightroom remains the gold standard in pro photo workflow software. No doubt the program struggled to shake its early reputation. Apple aperture gets the best shot to replace iphoto on macapple devices. Perhaps, and this is maybe me being overly optimistic, the reason photos does not have these functions is because apple. A quick walkthrough of an editing session in lightroom for aperture. However, if youre used to the adobe suite of products, including photoshop, then lightroom. Photo ninja up until now, i assumed lightroom and aperture were the main options, but im reading that capture one and photo ninja are superior in their raw handling abilities, speed, and image quality at the expense of some features. Best nondestructive editing software for photography. Both offer a unique way to enjoy your digital images, but the final quality of the product tends to lean toward adobe lightroom. Theres a lot of debate on what these tests actually mean, i wanted to share my thoughts. Use 1 of these photo managers if you care about your photo. And fast to update a folder generally, a pita is that you cant force it to.
In fact, there are tools available from adobe to convert aperture libraries into. Jul 28, 20 you are absolutely correct, there are many features which make picasa superior to iphoto. And just to throw another spanner in the works aperture on my new macbook pro is also way faster than lightroom but not yet as fast as picasa on the very fast pc. The best photo editing suite for macos adobe lightroom cc. Apple should be releasing the new photos app sometime in the new year. While i still prefer classic, here are 5 options for you instead of lightroom. Both actually store photos in a browsable folder heiarchy you have to navigate into the aperture.
Id give it a try to see if you find it usable before looking at lightroom. Lightroom could give us something like aperture s loupe and definitely aperture s speed. With respect to choosing between aperture vs lightroom, think about which company is going to support you the best longterm. The results as published by infotrends, an independent research firm, were conclusive in that lightroom was the application of choice for pro photographers. Both of which are no longer available from apple, and for good reason. Lightroom will operate comfortably with less than half of that. I also wanted to compare aperture my current tool of choice with adobe camera raw lightroom. However, if youre used to the adobe suite of products, including photoshop, then lightroom might be more intuitive.
Making the right choice were you wanting to find the difference between the full version of photoshop and lightroom. Theyre going to continue refining the plugin and will include it in a future lightroom update and its now included in lightroom 5. Note that moving a photo to another event is trivially easy simply flag the photos and go to the destination event, select it and use the add flagged photos to selected event command imho an easier and better solution than dragging between multiple windows. What can aperture or lightroom do that picasa or iphoto. Both do a great job and have similar feature sets comparing version 2 of each. I shoot canon with 12 mp images, only rarely raw, and my memory of. Why is adobe lightroom much better and faster than picassa. Mar 21, 20 ok you have the correct solution you do not like iphoto so use a different program no reason in the world to live annoyed. So you would run them sidebyside, organizing in one and processing in the other. With apple dropping aperture, would lightroom be a better replacement than pse. With the photoshop lightroom cloud offering and apple killing aperture, expect the next version of lightroom. A few years ago, this program was more expensive than lightroom. Aperture is cheaper than lr and purchasing it on the mac app store, will give you a license for every. Aperture and lightroom seem to be a matter of preference, but im not sure of what they offer in comparison to photoshop elements.
I personally use lightroom and acdsee pro 9 quite a bit, but after testing. Aperture is cheaper than lr and purchasing it on the mac app store, will give you a license for every computer connected to your appleid. You are absolutely correct, there are many features which make picasa superior to iphoto. Its natural for folks to want to take sides, and pick one program over the other. Adobe doubling down on lightroom in wake of apples. Why killing aperture means apple will rule the cloud. Both apple aperture and adobe lightroom offer similar photo editing and photo. In june of 2014, we all learned that apple had been building a whole new photo managing program called photos for mac os x. What software for processing and cataloging raw images should a new customer buy. I love apple, especially while steve jobs was at the helm. For technical reasons, macos mojave is the last version of macos to run aperture. Storage and sharing flickr vs smugmug vs picasa vs icloud vs dropbox.
Picasa in reply to nir nussbaum may 27, 2007 i just upgraded to a mac macbook pro, 2 gig ram, 160 gig hd and the software i miss the most is picasa. Im currently using photoshop lightroom and have been for a couple of years now. I can, of course, speak only for myself, but i have moved from dpp to lr because of lrs tool set, the free rotation tool, the. I remember when i first switched to lightroom from aperture rip, i was surprised by how cluttered it felt. Picktorial 4 a potential nocost replacement for apple aperture.
Instructions how to store your photos inside of iphoto, or outside in folders anywhere you. Programs like lightroom and aperture are the more pro versions, where you can do much more serious editing, tagging, processing, etc and automate a lot of actions that might be useful for providing your. Two top programs that are considered for digital media management today are adobe lightroom and picasa. Aperture, photos is now the only photo managing application apple is currently supporting. Adobe lightroom gives users the option to create photo books directly. Why lightroom is best for beginning photographers improve. It has been around since 2004 as an easy, free way for sharing photos before other services like icloud and flickr became more popular. Basically, what are the differences between picasa and lightroom. What can aperture or lightroom do that picasa or iphoto cant. Many people after five or ten years might have more than 50k. While both aperture and lightroom perform the role of image manager and photo editor admirably, each program has plenty of unique features that set it apart. I can, of course, speak only for myself, but i have moved from dpp to lr because of lrs tool set, the free rotation tool, the digital graduated density filter and the local adjustments brush. A quick overview of lightroom for aperture users youtube.
Picasa has a different purpose than adobe lightroom. I know its geared toward togs, but how is it different. Before that, there were management apps like imatch or iview mediapro and processing apps like rawshooter and bibble. Those who take digital photography seriously need the right software to import, organize, correct, and disseminate their work. Also, i naively thought that aperture was a large photolibrary management application. A nice touch is the option boxes for windows, mac os and unix to. I can tell you without a doubt it is far superior to iphoto or aperture. Can someone tell me again why the paidfor lightroom is better than the free picasa.
It doesnt work with photoshop any better than aperture. The glimmer of hope is that they will change aperture so it can reference massive amounts of pictures that span multiple drives. Apple officially announced that on any future macos, aperture will not run. Both adobe lightroom and aperture allow users to assign keywords to their images. Lightroom has a history panel and you can go back to any adjustment you made on an image from today, or weeks ago, and undo to a specific step or start over. Apple aperture and lightroom pioneered combining image management with image processing.
I made the switch from aperture to photos jeff geerling. Like similar modes in iphoto, aperture, and lightroom, acdsee pro. You do have to back up and optimize the catalogue periodically i have it set as a default to do this when i close. Whether youre a casual smartphone shooter or a professional using an slr, software can get the most out of your. Should i store my photo collection in iphoto or elsewhere on. I was wondering if i should also consider aperture or lightroom rather than picasa, but i dont have a good idea of what aperture or lightroom can do that picasa or iphoto cant, so i wanted to ask. What are the differences between picasa and lightroom, other. In some respects it doesnt even compare favorably to iphoto or picasa. Before we begin discussing nuts, bolts and how many angels can dance on the head of a pin, lets set some parameters so we know what were looking for. Lightroom usage and the figures although the sample is smaller about 100 are vastly different from the figures above. Compared to lightroom classic cc, lightroom cc has no print module or. Its a complete package, with topnotch organization tools, state oftheart adjustments, and all the output. Lightroom has a powerful blurb book creation tool built right in which ive written about on the blog.
Since apple released aperture 3 a few weeks ago lots of folks are debating the pros and cons of lightroom vs. Photo management iphoto vs aperture vs picasa macrumors. Later in the same month, apple dropped a bomb and declared they were also ceasing future development of both of their current applications iphoto and aperture. Oct 16, 2014 adobe has just released their first apertureiphoto to lightroom import tool.
1296 773 1320 507 143 1520 587 111 1045 1325 444 1069 415 1330 1011 1081 1064 81 1294 427 533 1541 747 615 1131 1023 36 194 508 1243 231 87 1001 1355 467 267 1044 1154 608 819 497 223 536 671